Alligator Alcatraz guard sentenced to one year probation in detainee beating case
Published in News & Features
MIAMI — A guard at the now-shuttered immigration detention center in the Everglades known as Alligator Alcatraz was sentenced Wednesday after pleading no contest to a battery charge for allegedly beating a detainee. The case is likely the first in which the courts have held someone who worked at the facility accountable for mistreating the people in their custody.
Andre Junior Seenaraine, 30, who was sentenced to 12 months probation with no early termination, was one of two guards investigated by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and charged by Collier County prosecutors for striking detainee Rigoberto Rodriguez Arce while transporting him during a Jan. 25 incident in which detainees had begun banging their handcuffs after going hours without water and food.
Collier County Judge Deborah Cunningham, who was appointed to the bench by Gov. Ron DeSantis, also in her Nov. 18 ruling ordered Seenaraine to complete 30 hours of community service, barred him from contacting the victim and required him to enroll in anger management classes within 30 days.
Evan Pfeifer, Seenaraine’s attorney, said though his client resolved the case with a plea of no contest, he “does not admit the allegations, but he chose not to contest them. Under a sentence agreed upon by the State and the defense, the court adjudicated him guilty of misdemeanor battery and placed him on probation.
“Although the alleged victim has spoken to several media outlets about this case, he did not appear at the hearing, and no one spoke or presented a statement on his behalf,” he said. “Because a related case remains pending, we will not be commenting further on the underlying facts.”
In an interview with Wink, Rodriguez said the guards punched him in the face and smashed his nose to the ground while he was restrained. He described the experience as almost being killed by the guards who pounded on him, and said his only escape was to pretend he was losing consciousness so they would stop.
Rodriguez’s lawyers did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The case highlights some of the complaints from detainees and their families about inhumane treatment while at the detention center, which closed in June. Their complaints were met with beatings, pepper spray and, at times, confinement in a phone-book-sized cage called ‘the box.’
The Department of Homeland Security and the DeSantis administration have continued to deny allegations of detainee mistreatment, despite a federal inspector general report that found the use of restrictive cages did not align with the standards of humane treatment.
The Florida Division of Emergency Management, which oversaw operations at the facility, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The other guard charged in the incident, Stephen Jordan Trejos, has asked for the case be dismissed, citing Florida’s stand-your-ground laws as a reason he should not be prosecuted for striking Rodriguez.
Trejos’ lawyers argue that, during the incident, he was transporting Rodriguez after he and other detainees started causing a commotion. They said Rodriguez spat on Trejos, who responded with a “single compliance strike” to the side of his head. At one point, they said, Trejos thought Rodriguez was about to spit on him again, so he and another officer took Rodriguez down.
Lawyers for Seenaraine and his booking report confirmed he worked for Critical Response Strategies, a private contractor hired by the state to oversee the detention center. The company did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
©2026 Miami Herald. Visit at miamiherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments